React Query and Redux are two libraries for managing state in React applications, but they have distinct focuses and use cases.
-
Design Purpose:
- React Query is specifically designed for handling asynchronous data (server state), such as fetching data from APIs, caching results, and data synchronization.
- Redux is a more general-purpose state management library that provides a predictable state container for JavaScript applications, primarily used for managing client-side state (UI state).
-
Data Caching and Invalidations:
- React Query includes built-in mechanisms for data caching and automatic invalidation. It automatically re-fetches data in the background and marks it as stale when data becomes outdated.
- Redux itself does not provide these features directly. Implementing data caching and invalidation in Redux typically requires additional middleware or manual logic.
-
Data Synchronization and Updates:
- React Query provides built-in tools for handling data queries, mutations, updates, and synchronization, reducing boilerplate code.
- Redux requires manual management of data synchronization and updates, often involving writing actions, reducers, and using middleware for asynchronous logic, which can increase boilerplate.
-
Configuration and Boilerplate:
- React Query is typically more concise to use, with hooks like
useQueryanduseMutationenabling direct data requests within components. - Redux configuration is relatively complex, especially during initial setup, requiring definitions of actions, reducers, and store creation, though Redux Toolkit reduces some boilerplate.
- React Query is typically more concise to use, with hooks like
-
Development Philosophy:
- React Query aims to simplify server state handling by encouraging direct data loading from components without global state overhead.
- Redux follows Functional Programming principles, using pure reducers and immutable data to manage state, facilitating easier state change tracking and time-travel debugging.
-
Community and Ecosystem:
- React Query is popular for asynchronous data management but has a smaller ecosystem focused on data fetching and caching.
- Redux boasts a large community and ecosystem with numerous middleware and libraries, such as
redux-thunk,redux-saga,reselect, andredux-form.
Example:
Suppose your application needs to fetch a user list from a REST API and display the latest data. Using React Query, you can do this:
jsximport { useQuery } from 'react-query'; function UsersComponent() { const { data, error, isLoading } = useQuery('users', fetchUsers); // Render your UI based on the data, error, and loading state... }
In this example, fetchUsers is an asynchronous function that requests data from the API. useQuery automatically handles data loading, caching, re-fetching, and updates.
In Redux, you might need to create actions and reducers to handle asynchronous requests and use middleware like redux-thunk:
jsximport { useDispatch, useSelector } from 'react-redux'; function UsersComponent() { const dispatch = useDispatch(); const { users, error, isLoading } = useSelector(state => state.users); useEffect(() => { dispatch(fetchUsers()); }, [dispatch]); // Render your UI based on the users, error, and loading state... }
React Query and Redux are two distinct libraries serving different roles in React applications.
React Query is a library for data fetching, caching, synchronization, and updates. It focuses on asynchronous data operations, such as API data retrieval, caching results, and automatic re-fetching. Key features include:
- Automatic Caching and Invalidations: React Query automatically caches request results and provides mechanisms to re-fetch data when changes occur.
- Background Synchronization: Supports automatic updates in the background during data changes or user interactions.
- Query State: Provides rich state information (e.g., loading, error, data states) for UI display.
- Minimal Global State Management: Aims to manage server state with minimal configuration.
Redux is a library providing a predictable state container for JavaScript applications, particularly suited for React. It manages global application state through actions and reducers. Key features include:
- Global State Management: Uses a single state tree with changes managed via dispatched actions and reducers.
- Predictability: Ensures consistent behavior through a clear state change process.
- Middleware: Supports extensions like
redux-thunkfor asynchronous handling and logging. - Development Tools: Includes tools like Redux DevTools for tracking state changes and action dispatches.
Key Differences:
- Purpose: React Query is primarily for data synchronization, while Redux is for global state management.
- Data Management: React Query includes built-in caching mechanisms, whereas Redux requires manual handling of data requests and responses.
- State Synchronization: React Query provides automatic synchronization, while Redux needs additional libraries (e.g.,
redux-thunk) for asynchronous logic. - Configuration: React Query reduces boilerplate, while Redux requires more setup steps.
- Development Experience: React Query's API aligns with React hooks, while Redux demands adherence to specific patterns and best practices.
For example, fetching a user list with React Query:
javascriptimport { useQuery } from 'react-query'; function Users() { const { isLoading, error, data } = useQuery('fetchUsers', fetchUsersApi); if (isLoading) return 'Loading...'; if (error) return 'An error has occurred: ' + error.message; return ( <ul> {data.map(user => ( <li key={user.id}>{user.name}</li> ))} </ul> ); } async function fetchUsersApi() { const response = await fetch('/api/users'); if (!response.ok) { throw new Error('Network response was not ok'); } return response.json(); }
Using Redux for the same task:
javascriptimport { createStore, applyMiddleware } from 'redux'; import thunk from 'redux-thunk'; import { Provider, useDispatch, useSelector } from 'react-redux'; // Action types const FETCH_USERS_REQUEST = 'FETCH_USERS_REQUEST'; const FETCH_USERS_SUCCESS = 'FETCH_USERS_SUCCESS'; const FETCH_USERS_FAILURE = 'FETCH_USERS_FAILURE'; // Action creators const fetchUsersRequest = () => ({ type: FETCH_USERS_REQUEST }); const fetchUsersSuccess = users => ({ type: FETCH_USERS_SUCCESS, payload: